Compare
Cash buyer vs iBuyer in Utah, fee by fee.
Both of us pay cash and both of us move quickly. The difference is what comes off the number afterwards, and which houses each of us will take at all.
Two cash offers are not the same offer
The cash buyer vs iBuyer question sounds like it should be simple, because on the surface the two products look identical. Put in your address, get a number without listing the house, close on a date you choose, skip the showings. Where they part company is what happens between the number you're quoted and the money you're paid.
An iBuyer prices from software. Public records, recent sales, square footage, year built, and a model that has to be cautious because nobody from the company has seen the house. That's a real advantage on a house that looks ordinary in the data: their instant offer can start higher than ours, and we'll say so.
Then the deductions start. A service fee comes off the top, typically around 5% of the price, which is a listing commission by another name. An inspection follows, and whatever it finds is itemized and taken off as well. The number you sign can end up some way below the one that arrived in your inbox on day one, and how far below depends on the house.
Our number has one deduction, and it's already applied. Condition is priced in at the start, which is why there's no inspection contingency in our contract and no service fee anywhere in it. What Property Seller Solutions offers is what the title company wires you, less only what's already owed against the property.
Where an iBuyer will beat us, and you should let them
If your house was built in the last twenty or thirty years, it's in good condition, it sits in a zip code they cover, and you don't need anything unusual from the sale, an iBuyer will often net you more than we can. Their model is built for exactly that house: light repairs, fast resale, low risk, so they can pay closer to retail. Take the higher number.
We're built for the other house. The 1960s rambler with a failed furnace. The house with a tenant who stopped paying. Fire damage, foundation movement, an unpermitted addition, forty years of belongings in the basement, a probate case still open. Software declines those houses, or prices them as though the worst is true. A person walking through it can price what's actually there.
Most Utah houses still change hands the ordinary way. Roughly nine sellers in ten worked with an agent, according to the National Association of Realtors' profile of home buyers and sellers, and if your house is in good shape that route is still worth pricing. We set it out on cash buyer vs realtor.
Cash buyer vs iBuyer, line by line.
The condition row is the one that decides it for most people. Read the last row before you call us, because that is the one where they beat us.
| Feature | Property Seller Solutions | Typical iBuyer |
|---|---|---|
| Service fee | $0 | About 5% of the offer |
| Repair deductions | None. Priced in up front | Itemized after their inspection |
| Who you talk to | A local person, by name | An app, then a support line |
| Condition accepted | Any condition at all | Newer homes in good shape |
| Offer changes | No. The number holds | Can be revised after inspection |
| Closing date | You pick it | Inside their window |
| Likely offer on a newer home | Below full retail | Can start closer to retail |
The concession: on a newer house in good condition, in a zip code they buy in, an iBuyer can pay more than we can, because their costs after the sale are lower than ours. If that's your house, take their number. We'd rather lose it than talk you out of the better deal.
What to expect from each of us
Both routes are easiest to judge by walking through them, so here they are, from the first click or the first phone call to the day the money lands.
Selling to an iBuyer
You enter the address on a website and answer questions about the house. Photographs help. A preliminary number comes back quickly, sometimes in minutes, which is the whole appeal of an instant offer and a genuinely useful thing to have.
If you accept in principle, an inspection is scheduled, either in person or by video. What it finds is written up as a repair estimate and deducted from the price, and the revised offer is the one you actually sign. The service fee comes off separately. Closing is arranged inside a window the company sets, usually a few weeks out, and everything after that happens by email.
It works. For the right house it works well, and for a seller who wants no conversation at all it may be exactly right. Three things are worth doing before you sign: read the clause that lets the price change after the inspection, ask for the total of every fee in dollars rather than percentages, and ask whether anything is owed if you change your mind and cancel. Those three answers turn a quoted number into a real one.
Selling to us
You call (385) 503-4333 and a person in Utah answers, from 8am to 7pm, seven days a week. We ask three things: where the house is, what state it's in, and when you need to be out. Then somebody drives out and walks through it, once.
The offer comes in writing inside 24 hours with the three figures behind it: what comparable houses nearby actually closed at, what the repairs cost, and what it costs us to hold and resell. You can argue with any of them, and people do. If you accept, we close at a Utah title company on the date you picked, 7 days or 60. If you want the sequence in more detail, it's on sell my house fast, and what the paperwork contains is on cash offer.
Is this you?
A local cash buyer is usually the better fit when one of these is true:
- The house is older, or needs work an inspection would turn into a long list
- An iBuyer has already declined it, or their number dropped after the inspection
- There's a tenant in place, or somebody living there who isn't leaving for a walkthrough
- The house is part of an estate, a divorce, or anything with paperwork attached
- You want to ask a person a question and get an answer the same day
- The closing date has to be yours rather than somebody's scheduling window
- You've been told the house falls outside what they buy in your part of Utah
If your house is newer and tidy, get an instant offer first and use it as a floor. Then get ours, and compare the two after every fee and deduction, not before. The seven questions worth asking any buyer, us included, are on companies that buy houses. We've bought 1,300+ houses in Utah since 2016, hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, and average 4.9 across 520 Google reviews. When you want a second number to set beside the first, get your cash offer and we'll call you back within one business day.
Sellers who compared two offers, then picked ours.
Real reviews, left on Google, by Utah homeowners who sold us their houses.
“One of the smoothest deals I've been part of. Communication was prompt, clear and collaborative the whole way through.”
“Fast and efficient. They made a fair, generous offer and we closed in five days.”
“I inherited my mother's house and had no idea where to start. They made it simple, respectful and stress-free.”
“You can tell they genuinely care about helping sellers. Responsive, and they handled everything with compassion.”
Questions sellers ask about the two kinds of cash offer.
What is an iBuyer?
A company that uses software to price houses and buys them directly, without listing them, then resells them. The name is short for instant buyer, and the instant part is real: the first number often comes back the same day. They're national businesses working in defined metro areas and defined zip codes, so whether one is buying near you depends on where the house is. It costs nothing to put your address in and find out.
Why does the iBuyer number start higher than yours?
Because it's priced before anybody has seen the house, and because their fee is collected separately rather than built into the price. A service fee of roughly 5% comes off, and a repair deduction usually follows the inspection. Ours is one number with the condition already inside it and nothing taken off afterwards. Compare the two at the end of the process rather than the beginning, and ask both of us for the figure that would land in your account.
Can an iBuyer lower the offer after the inspection?
Most agreements allow a revision once the house has been inspected, which is a reasonable thing for a buyer who priced it sight unseen. Whether it happens, and by how much, is a question for them, and the answer is in the contract rather than on the website. Ask for that clause in writing before you sign anything. Our contract has no inspection contingency at all, which is the same promise from the other direction.
How do I compare the two offers fairly?
The cash buyer vs iBuyer comparison only becomes a fair one at the end of the process, so write both offers on the same piece of paper as net dollars rather than percentages. Take the iBuyer number, subtract the service fee, subtract whatever repair deduction they've quoted or, if the inspection hasn't happened yet, ask what the typical deduction is on a house of that age. Compare what's left with our written offer, which has nothing further to subtract. Then check the dates, because a sale that closes three weeks later than you need is worth less than the difference on the page.
Find out what your house is worth in cash. Free, and no strings.
One phone call, or one short form. You'll have a real number by this time tomorrow.
Tell us about the house
Where the house is, your name, and a number we can reach you on. We call back within one business day, and you're free to say no.
